ABA vs Other Autism Therapies: Understanding Your Options
Compare ABA therapy to other autism treatments including speech therapy, occupational therapy, and developmental approaches. Learn how therapies work together.
Shamay Selim, M.Ed., BCBA
Clinical Director at Foundations Autism
Navigating Autism Therapy Options
When your child is diagnosed with autism, you'll encounter many therapy options. Understanding the differences between ABA and other interventions helps you build a comprehensive treatment plan. This guide compares major therapies and explains how they can work together.
ABA Therapy Overview
Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) is considered the gold standard treatment for autism, backed by decades of research:
- Focus: Behavior change and skill development across all areas
- Approach: Data-driven, systematic, individualized
- Typical hours: 10-40 hours per week
- Providers: BCBAs and RBTs
- Strengths: Strong research base, comprehensive, measurable progress
- Addresses: Communication, social skills, behavior, academics, daily living
Speech-Language Therapy
Speech-Language Pathology (SLP) addresses communication disorders:
- Focus: Speech, language, and communication skills
- Approach: Clinical assessment and targeted intervention
- Typical hours: 1-5 hours per week
- Providers: Speech-Language Pathologists (SLPs)
- Strengths: Specialized communication expertise
- Addresses: Articulation, language comprehension, social communication, feeding/swallowing
ABA vs Speech Therapy
| Aspect | ABA | Speech Therapy |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Comprehensive (all behaviors and skills) | Communication-focused |
| Intensity | High (10-40 hrs/week) | Low-moderate (1-5 hrs/week) |
| Setting | Home, center, school | Clinic, school, telehealth |
| Best for | Functional communication use | Speech mechanics, language disorders |
How they complement: SLPs address the mechanics of speech and complex language disorders, while ABA focuses on teaching children to use communication functionally across settings. Many children benefit from both.
Occupational Therapy (OT)
Occupational Therapy helps children participate in daily activities:
- Focus: Fine motor skills, sensory processing, daily living skills
- Approach: Activity-based, sensory integration
- Typical hours: 1-3 hours per week
- Providers: Occupational Therapists (OTs)
- Strengths: Sensory expertise, motor skill development
- Addresses: Handwriting, self-care, sensory needs, motor planning
ABA vs Occupational Therapy
| Aspect | ABA | Occupational Therapy |
|---|---|---|
| Scope | Behavior and skills broadly | Motor, sensory, daily activities |
| Self-care | Task analysis, behavioral teaching | Motor components, adaptive equipment |
| Sensory | Behavioral approaches to tolerance | Sensory integration, sensory diets |
| Best for | Learning new behaviors and routines | Motor skills, sensory processing |
How they complement: OTs address underlying motor and sensory issues that may affect skill development. ABA can build on OT progress to teach functional use of skills.
Developmental/Relationship-Based Approaches
Several therapies focus on developmental and relationship aspects:
DIR/Floortime
- Focus: Emotional and developmental foundations through play
- Approach: Child-led, relationship-focused
- Philosophy: Meet child at their level, build engagement
- Strengths: Child-centered, builds connection
- Research: Moderate evidence base, less robust than ABA
RDI (Relationship Development Intervention)
- Focus: Dynamic thinking, flexible problem-solving
- Approach: Parent-delivered, guided participation
- Philosophy: Build dynamic intelligence through relationships
- Strengths: Family-centered, addresses flexibility
- Research: Limited research base
Comparison with ABA
| Aspect | ABA | DIR/Floortime |
|---|---|---|
| Structure | More structured | Child-led |
| Data | Systematic data collection | Observation-based |
| Focus | Behavior and skills | Emotional development |
| Research | Extensive evidence | Moderate evidence |
Note: Modern ABA often incorporates naturalistic, play-based methods, making it more similar to developmental approaches than historical ABA.
Social Skills Groups
Many children benefit from peer-based social skills training:
- Focus: Social interaction with peers
- Approach: Group activities, role-play, coaching
- Typical format: Weekly 1-2 hour groups
- Providers: Various (SLPs, psychologists, BCBAs)
- Strengths: Peer practice, real-world skills
How it complements ABA: ABA can teach social skills individually, and groups provide opportunities to practice with peers. Some ABA centers offer social skills groups as part of services.
Building a Comprehensive Treatment Plan
Most children benefit from multiple therapies working together:
- ABA as the foundation: Comprehensive skill building and behavior support
- Speech therapy: For specific communication needs
- Occupational therapy: For motor and sensory support
- Social skills groups: For peer practice
Coordination is Key
Ensure your providers communicate:
- Share goals and progress across therapies
- Align strategies so they complement each other
- Avoid contradictory approaches
- Balance total therapy hours to prevent burnout
Choosing the Right Combination
Consider these factors:
- Your child's needs: What areas require the most support?
- Insurance coverage: What therapies are covered?
- Availability: What services are accessible in your area?
- Total hours: How much can your child handle?
- Family capacity: What can you realistically manage?
Frequently Asked Questions
Common questions about this topic.
ABA and speech therapy serve different but complementary purposes. ABA focuses on overall behavior and skill development, while speech therapy specifically targets communication disorders. Most children benefit from both services working together. Speech therapists address the mechanics of speech, while ABA therapists help children use communication functionally.
ABA therapy uses behavioral principles to teach a wide range of skills and address behaviors. Occupational therapy focuses specifically on fine motor skills, sensory processing, and daily living activities. Both can address some overlapping areas like self-care skills, but from different perspectives. Many children benefit from both therapies.
Floortime (DIR) and ABA take different approaches—Floortime is play-based and child-led, focusing on emotional development, while ABA is more structured and data-driven. Research supports ABA more strongly, but some families prefer Floortime's approach. Many modern ABA programs incorporate play-based, naturalistic methods. The best approach depends on your child's needs and your family's values.
Yes, most children with autism receive multiple therapies simultaneously. A typical treatment plan might include ABA therapy, speech therapy, and occupational therapy. The key is ensuring therapies complement each other and providers communicate. Your BCBA can help coordinate services for the best outcomes.
Related Articles
Continue learning with these related guides.
Ready to find an ABA provider?
Search our directory of verified ABA therapy providers across all 50 states.